Noeo Science Curriculum Review

Noeo Science is a rare jewel for Charlotte Mason homeschoolers. Miss Mason felt that nature study was adequate science instruction for elementary children. But for eclectic homeschoolers who desire a more structured science curriculum in addition to nature study, Noeo fits the bill.

Noeo is not a textbook but a literature based curriculum with options for grades K-6.  You can choose from one of three areas–chemistry, physics, or biology.  Your set includes an instructor’s guide, living science books, biographies of scientists, and experiment kits.  The spiral bound, three –hole punched instructor’s guide has readings laid out for 4 days for each of the 36 weeks.  The schedule is light and thus meets Miss Mason’s recommendation for short lessons.

The instructor’s guide is really more of a schedule than a teaching guide. As Miss Mason would have it, the books are meant to speak directly to the child, so there is no need for lengthy teaching notes. There is absolutely no busy work in this program. There are only reading, experiments, and narrating.  Generally, the only notes in the instructor’s guide are “read the assigned pages and describe and/or sketch what you learned in your science notebook.”  This type of activity is narration, exactly what Charlotte Mason recommended.  Sometimes the instructor’s guide points out key vocabulary words to define, and when experiments are scheduled, there is a supply list.

The experiments are from Young Scientist Club Kits and from Ein’O Kits. The supplies are all included, and the directions are very clear. I found that each experiment really worked well to give us a concrete illustration of what we’d been reading about. Noeo supplies a blank experiment template to document each project.

Noeo Science also has a Yahoo group where you can get help at any time. Once I could not understand one of our physics experiments, so I posted a question on the group. Randy Pritchard, the creator of Noeo science, responded to my question with a clear explanation. And after that, we were able to successfully complete the experiment.

How does Noeo compare to Sonlight science? Although they both use living books and experiments, Noeo’s experiments are always related to the readings. And whereas Sonlight’s packages offer a broad view of many facets of science, Noeo focuses on just one area each year.  Noeo offers some blank notebooking templates, and Sonlight has activity sheets. Both use narration as a learning tool.

We have completed our study of Physics 1 (recommended for ages 5-8, grades 1-3). I found it a wonderful curriculum and am totally satisfied with the purchase. The books are colorful and engaging, the type that you don’t want to sell once the study is over. There is a definite structure, but it’s not so stifling that you can’t go off on tangents of your own.  The standard assignment after each reading is really just to narrate. You can do this orally, through a science notebook, through lapbooking, or whatever other method you prefer.

Written by Jimmie, Charlotte Mason flavored mom of one.

Jimmie (19 Posts)

Jimmie is mom to one creative teen. Jimmie's Collage is where she blogs about their Charlotte Mason styled homeschool. Her second blog, The Notebooking Fairy, features free notebooking printables and how-tos plus the eBook Notebooking Success.